Coming home from Andersons, after he only-half-jokingly apologized for not knowing whether the beef he bought was local (did I mention I got him to read Animal, Vegetable, Miracle?), Eric and I discussed pasta sauce. We love Trader Joe’s basil marinara, you see. It’s tasty, it works as pizza sauce, it costs $2 a jar. But Trader Joe’s is an hour away, and gas is expensive. “Could we make our own version?” Eric wondered aloud.
“I’m sure we could,” I said. “It might take a few attempts.”
“How much do tomato plants cost?” Eric said.
“Two dollars each at the store,” I said. “But since my seeds are mostly free except for postage, they’ll be essentially free for us.”
“Essentially free pasta sauce would be essentially awesome,” he said.
We figured it out thus:
- The sauce is mostly tomatoes; tomatoes are mostly water; a quart of sauce is tomatoes somewhat thickened; call it two pounds per quart.
- We use pasta sauce for pasta, for lasagna, in pizza, in occasional other things. Call it a jar a week on average. In the summer we can make fresh; but the rest of the year, we’ll need to can our own. Call it forty weeks’ worth.
- We also need tomatoes for other things, like gazpacho (“Mmm, gazpacho,” Eric said, looking into the distance. “With our own tomatoes, our own cucumbers, and our own peppers.”) and ratatouille and salsa. And drying.
- That’s eighty pounds of sauce, plus some unknown number extra tomatoes. I want to try canning salsa as well, and we like gazpacho. Call it a hundred and twenty pounds of tomatoes, all told.
- With ideal conditions, tomato plants can apparently produce up to 100 lb. of fruit in a season, but the average is more like 10 lb.
- I went back through last year’s log and calculated that leaving out the cherries and Romas (which I think is fair, because the former are not for sauce and the Romas were choked out by the cherries before they got a decent chance), my plants averaged 7.8 pounds of tomatoes each. I plan to take better care of my plants this year and I believe I can achieve the 10 pounds. (Also, I only got 5 lb off my Cherokee Purple plant last year, which is inexpressibly sad.)
- This means I need at least to grow 12 healthy tomato plants, other than the grape tomato, preferably mainly ones that aren’t too juicy and will therefore be good for sauce.
“We need to work on our pickle recipe too,” Eric fretted.
“For that, we’ll want all our pickle cucumbers at once,” I said. “I planted two last year.”
“Double that would be nice. Plus cucumbers for eating.”
“If we were staying in this house any longer, I get the feeling the garden would be expanding even more next year.”
“Oh, yeah.”



8 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 17, 2008 at 8:44 pm
Meg
Damn, TJ’s sauce is good isn’t it? We’re partial to their vodka sauce. mmm.
I think if you grow some paste tomatoes, you’ll definitely hit the 10 pound average. We had two or three Roma tomato plants and got about 40 pounds out of them. I like your method of figuring how much you’ll need to grow. I should get to calculating the same for us!
February 20, 2008 at 5:08 pm
Weeping Sore
You didn’t factor in the satisfaction you derive from growing your own food, even before you eat it. Or the better nutritional value and taste. May you can long and prosper.
February 22, 2008 at 10:45 am
Jenny
I’ve never tried the vodka sauce, Meg, but I’ll have to do that sometime. And I’m glad to hear that about the paste tomatoes.
And WS, as for satisfaction, nutrition and taste, those were pretty much givens. It’s not so far to TJ’s, if we stock up all at once; but making our own will be much, much better. As long as the price of glass jars doesn’t go up, we’re good.
February 23, 2008 at 5:29 am
Melinda
Homemade is soooo much tastier, too! Yum. We had about 60 lbs per tomato plant, on average last year. And we we would have had more had we planted them earlier (we moved in May). I think it had a lot to do with the compost. And sheer determination to have darn good tomato sauce!
Through some crazy calculations about as scientific as yours, I found that we saved about $719.90. LOL. Here’s that post: http://tinyurl.com/23uept
Oh, and don’t shy away from making sauce out of cherry tomatoes. That’s our favorite by far – a sweeter, more complex sauce!
February 23, 2008 at 5:20 pm
Jenny
That’s amazing, Melinda. And I’ll have to try the cherry tomato sauce, in that case. I have bags of them in the freezer because I couldn’t think of how to use them all up last summer. Do you peel them?
February 24, 2008 at 11:51 pm
kate
I don’t peel the cherry tomatoes when I make sauce with them. But I haven’t tried it from the frozen article. I don’t think I’d bother.
I love the maths. My calculations are strictly ‘how many plants can we squeeze into this tiny garden?’, then we eat whatever turns up from that.
I think we’ll need a bigger garden too.
February 26, 2008 at 8:49 am
Jenny
Good to know, Kate. I’ve made sauce from unpeeled tomatoes and I notice the peels, but they don’t really bother me–but with a higher peel-to-sauce ratio with the cherries I wasn’t sure. And there was some “How many plants can we squeeze in” to our calculations too.
May 12, 2008 at 7:57 pm
A real gardener « Seeded
[...] in the driveway bed that are almost the same size. I’m not feeling so sanguine about that one hundred and twenty pounds of tomatoes anymore. Still, I put my stakes up first and buried the plants deeply and sprinkled a mixture of [...]